Source: http://gmatgremath.blogspot.comIf
m and
n are positive numbers, is sqrt(
m²
n² + 676) ≥ sqrt(4
m²
n² + 1) ?
(1) 24 ≥
mn(2)
m ≥ 16/
nAs it is phrased, the question is not in the most simplified form. The statements will be much easier to evaluate if we do some algebra to simplify the original expression. One must be careful in simplifying the square roots correctly; this question is made to trip test takers who don't know the correct rules. To illustrate where the trap is, we will simplify it the
right way and the
wrong way.
Right Way:First, square both sides of "sqrt(
m²
n² + 676) ≥ sqrt(4
m²
n² + 1) ?" to get
"
m²
n² + 676 ≥ 4
m²
n² + 1 ?"
Then, subtract
m²
n² and 1 from both sides to get
"675 ≥ 3
m²
n² ?"
Now, divide both sides by 3 to get
"225 ≥
m²
n² ?"
Lastly, take the square root of both sides to get
"15 ≥
mn ?"
So, what the question is really asking is whether 15 ≥
mn. Pretty easy!
Statement (1) is insufficient because it only tells us that
mn is less than or equal to 24, but that doesn't tell us whether
mn is less than or equal to 15.
Statement (2) is equivalent to
mn ≥ 16; this is sufficient to answer the question with a definite "no." Thus, the correct answer is
B.
Here is the
Wrong Way:
Break up "sqrt(
m²
n² + 676) ≥ sqrt(4
m²
n² + 1) ?" into
"sqrt(
m²
n²) + sqrt(676) ≥ sqrt(4
m²
n²) + sqrt(1) ?"
Then, evaluate all the square roots to get
"
mn + 26 ≥ 2
mn + 1 ?"
Now, subtract
mn and 1 from both sides to get
"25 ≥
mn"
Notice that if you ended up with this inequality, Statement (1) would be sufficient, and Statement (2) would be insufficient. That's why it's important to simplify square roots the right way!